Essentials #3: Humanity (Genesis 1:26-3:21) | 9/26/2021

Genesis 1:26-3:21 | 9/26/21 | Will DuVal

What does it mean to be HUMAN? This is one of the most fascinating, weighty questions that we all, AS humans, must ask and answer for ourselves. 

In his recent book, “The Rise and Triumph of the Modern Self”, Dr. Carl Trueman traces the evolution of our understanding of the human “self” in the Western world throughout time:

For most of human history, our self-perception as a species could perhaps best be characterized as the “tribal self”. Who we were was defined in relationship to others, specifically, those closest to us, in our tribe. 

Equally foundational was the concept of the “worshipping self”; we found our identity vertically in relationship to God or “the gods”, whoever or whatever we worshipped

But with the dawn of the discipline of philosophy in ancient Greece in the 5th c. BC, we begin to see a new concept of self emerge: the “thinking self”, the introspective self; who I AM is NOW far less defined by anything external to me - whether it be my community or the god I worship - than what is INTERNAL. 

This was most epitomized, skipping WAY ahead in history for the sake of time, by the French philosopher Rene Descartes in the mid-17th c., who famously said, “I think therefore I am”; he identified being WITH thinking. With self-reflection.

18th c Empiricism emphasized the “discovering self”.

19th c. Idealism emphasized the “subjective self”.

The Industrial Revolution gave us the “working self”.

Karl Marx: the “communal self”. Darwin: the “animal self”. Freud and Jung: the “psychoanalyzed self”. Postmodernism: the “skeptical self”. The Sexual Revolution: the “liberated, autonomous self”

Such that today, we’ve arrived at concept of self that could fairly be described as the “Sovereign Self”. It’s considered a basic human right, in our society, to define one’s OWN self, even to the exclusion of all science and reason. As Trueman explains in his preface: “The origins of this book lie in my curiosity about how and why a particular statement has come to be regarded as coherent and meaningful today: “I am a woman trapped in a man’s body.” ...Less than thirty years ago… [nearly anyone who heard such a statement] would have burst out laughing and considered it incoherent gibberish. And yet today is it a sentence that many in our society regard as not only meaningful but so significant that to deny it or question it in some way is to reveal oneself as stupid and immoral.” (Trueman, 19)

That’s because in today’s world, self is king. “NO ONE ELSE gets to tell me who I am; not even GENETICS!” 

But, “there’s nothing new under the sun” (Ecc 1:9); Over 3 millennia ago, the Book of Judges described the people of Israel in much the same way: “In those days there was NO king in Israel. Everyone did what was right in his own eyes.” When we have no king, when we reject GOD as our king, we inevitably become gods unto ourselves - this is the “rise and triumph of the modern”… and the NOT-so-modern… self. The Sovereign self. 

Previous
Previous

Essentials #4: GOD'S PLAN (1 Peter 2:4-10) | 10/3/2021