“Advent: JOY” (Philippians 1-4) | 12/22/19

Philippians 1-4 | 12/22/19 | Will DuVal

This morning is the fourth Sunday of Advent, the 4 weeks in the church calendar leading up to Christmas. And we are studying the theme of JOY together. We’ve covered HOPE, peace, and now, we turn to JOY

I think it’s important, perhaps more so with JOY than with any of the other topics, to try and define it up front; what do we MEAN when we say that Advent “Tis the Season” for JOY? 

Dictionary.com defines joy as “the emotion of great delight or happiness caused by something exceptionally good or satisfying”. But immediately, from a Christian perspective, we find problems with such a definition. If joy is necessarily caused “by something exceptionally good or satisfying”, how do we explain the Bible’s description of believers as those who “[we] rejoice in our sufferings” (Rom 5:3)?

This paradox – rejoicing in suffering – has driven MANY Christians to attempt to differentiate between joy and HAPPINESS. Michael Houdmann says, “It is common today to hear believers speak of a difference between joy and happiness. The teaching usually makes the following points: 1) Happiness is a feeling, but joy is not. 2) Happiness is fleeting, but joy is everlasting. 3) Happiness depends on circumstances or other people, but joy is a gift from God. 4) Happiness is worldly, but joy is divine.” 

But is that really true? Are ANY of those 4 differentiations warranted, scripturally

  1. Is it true that “Happiness is a feeling, but joy is not”? In 1 Thessalonians 3:9, Paul describes “all the joy that we feel for your sake before our God”. So joy certainly can be a feeling, biblically. 

  2. Could it be that “Happiness is fleeting, but joy is everlasting”? Once again, that distinction too proves inaccurate - in Psalm 16:9, David writes “my heart is happy, and my whole being[e] rejoices; my flesh also dwells secure.” David uses poetic parallelism to draw a comparison, not a contrast, between happiness and joy here, and implies that BOTH can be secure, if our joy and happiness are found in the right place.

  3. So does “Happiness depend[s] on circumstances or other people, while joy is a gift from God”? Actually, we see LOTS of occasions in Scripture where joy is connected to a particular circumstance. 

    1. Deuteronomy 26:11 exhorts “You shall rejoice in all the good that the Lord your God has given to you”; we’re called to recognize the good circumstances the Lord has blessed us with, and let our gratitude lead us to JOY. 

    2. In Psalm 65, David expresses JOY that his fields are full of abundant flocks and a bountiful harvest. 

    3. Jeremiah 33:11 describes the joy of the bride and groom, at their wedding. 

    4. Proverbs 23:24 – parents will REJOICE in a righteous child.  

    5. Psalm 104 says that “wine brings joy to the heart of man” (take THAT, you Baptists!)

    6. Proverbs 5:18-19 “rejoice in the wife of your youth... Let her breasts fill you at all times with delight” (take THAT, you prudes!)

    7. Hebrews 11:25 goes so far as to acknowledge the possibility of “enjoy[ing] the fleeting pleasures of sin.” So it turns out joy can, and in at least some cases, SHOULD, in fact be derived from a particular set of circumstances. 

  4. Which leaves us with the last possible distinction: is it true that “Happiness is worldly, but joy is divine”? Well, Psalm 37:4 instructs us to “Delight yourself in the Lord”. Same root word as happiness. It is possible to find our HAPPINESS, as well as our joy, not in the things of this world, but in the Lord.

Previous
Previous

“Thinking on Our Ways, Turning Our Feet” (Psalm 119:57-64) | 12/29/19

Next
Next

“Advent: Peace” (John 14:15-27) | 12/15/19